Close Menu
Read Us 24×7
    What's Hot
    SOA OS23

    SOA OS23: The Future Blueprint for Scalable, Agile Digital Systems

    May 29, 2025
    Inter vs. Estrella Roja

    Inter vs. Estrella Roja: Full Match Guide and Detailed Stats

    May 29, 2025
    VCWeather

    VCWeather.org: The New Face of Hyperlocal Weather Reporting

    May 28, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest LinkedIn
    Trending
    • SOA OS23: The Future Blueprint for Scalable, Agile Digital Systems
    • Inter vs. Estrella Roja: Full Match Guide and Detailed Stats
    • VCWeather.org: The New Face of Hyperlocal Weather Reporting
    • Baltimore Orioles vs San Francisco Giants Match Player Stats
    • Benefits of Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana for Savings
    • 10 Best Automated Penetration Testing Tools
    • 7 Best Backlit Keyboards for Every Budget
    • Top 11 “Best Buy” Alternatives for Your Electronics Needs in 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest LinkedIn
    Read Us 24×7
    • Home
    • Technology
      SOA OS23

      SOA OS23: The Future Blueprint for Scalable, Agile Digital Systems

      May 29, 2025
      VCWeather

      VCWeather.org: The New Face of Hyperlocal Weather Reporting

      May 28, 2025
      Best Automated Penetration Testing Tools

      10 Best Automated Penetration Testing Tools

      May 13, 2025
      Backlit Keyboards

      7 Best Backlit Keyboards for Every Budget

      May 12, 2025
      Dark Oxygen

      Dark Oxygen: Redefining Our Understanding of Oxygen Production in the Deep Ocean

      May 9, 2025
    • Business
      Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana

      Benefits of Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana for Savings

      May 13, 2025
      7 Smart Ways to Earn Extra Money in 2025

      7 Smart Ways to Earn Extra Money in 2025

      May 10, 2025

      A Deeper Look at What It Is Like Working at a Prop Firm

      May 1, 2025
      FintechZoom.IO

      FintechZoom.IO: Revolutionizing Fintech in 2025

      April 7, 2025
      Crypto Management

      Unhosted: Revolutionizing Crypto Management with Advanced Wallet Technology

      March 20, 2025
    • Entertainment
      YouTube Audio Downloader

      YouTube Audio Downloader: Your Music Liberation Tool 🎵

      May 9, 2025
      Firestick

      10 Amazing Benefits of Owning a Firestick You Need to Know

      April 24, 2025
      nhentainet

      nhentai.net – Why It’s Attracting Global Attention?

      April 20, 2025
      chatgpts-ghibli-art-generator-goes-viral-why-is-everyone-obsessed

      ChatGPT’s Ghibli Art Generator Goes Viral – Why is Everyone Obsessed?

      March 29, 2025
      Taylor Swift's Producer Suggests New Album on the Horizon

      Taylor Swift’s Producer Suggests New Album on the Horizon

      March 28, 2025
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Tech Q&A
    Read Us 24×7
    Home » Can A Judge Overrule The Jury? Find Out Here!
    Lifestyle

    Can A Judge Overrule The Jury? Find Out Here!

    Sayan DuttaBy Sayan DuttaMay 27, 20237 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit Email WhatsApp
    Can A Judge Overrule The Jury
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Reddit WhatsApp

    The answer to this question is: it depends. In some cases, a judge can overrule the jury verdict and lower money damages, grant a judgment of acquittal, or order a new trial. 

    In other cases, the jury verdict is final and cannot be overturned by the judge. 

    The power and role of judges and juries in a court case vary depending on whether it is a criminal or civil case, and whether it is at the trial level or the appellate level.

    Understanding the Power and Role of Judges and Juries in a Court Case

    Judges’ Powers And Responsibilities

    Judges are responsible for overseeing the legal process and ensuring that the law is applied correctly and fairly. 

    Judges have the authority to:

    • Decide on pretrial motions, such as motions to dismiss, suppress evidence, or change venue.
    • Rule on objections and evidentiary issues during the trial.
    • Instruct the jury on the law and the elements of the case.
    • Determine the sentence or remedy in case of a conviction or a verdict for the plaintiff.
    • Grant post-trial motions, such as motions for a new trial, judgment notwithstanding the verdict (JNOV), or remittitur/additur.

    Jury’s Role In Determining Guilt Or Innocence

    Juries are composed of ordinary citizens who are randomly selected and sworn to hear the evidence and render a verdict based on the facts. Juries have the power to:

    • Evaluate the credibility and reliability of witnesses and evidence.
    • Weigh the arguments and evidence presented by both sides.
    • Apply the law as instructed by the judge to the facts of the case.
    • Reach a unanimous verdict of guilty or not guilty in criminal cases, or for or against the plaintiff in civil cases.

    When a Judge Can Overturn a Jury Verdict?

    1. JNOV (Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict)

    A JNOV, a law-based judgment, usually surfaces after a jury trial. This situation sees the judge overruling the jury’s decision, substituting it with a new one favoring the initially defeated party. 

    A JNOV is justifiable only if the judge ascertains that no rational jury could have arrived at such a verdict given the evidence. 

    For instance, when a party fails to provide evidence for a crucial aspect of their case, yet the jury rules in their favor, the judge has the power to overrule that, asserting that no rational jury would overlook the absence of evidence on that critical point, and then amend the judgment. 

    JNOVs appear more often in civil cases than criminal ones. In criminal proceedings, the judge rarely overturns an acquittal verdict, as this act infringes upon the defendant’s constitutional rights, including the right to a jury trial and protection from double jeopardy. 

    Nonetheless, should the jury pronounce the defendant guilty, the judge can permit a plea for acquittal judgment, either before or after the verdict, if the judge concludes that the evidence couldn’t establish the defendant’s guilt beyond any doubt.

    2. Limited Understanding of Legal Matters

    Sometimes, a judge may overrule a jury verdict because the jury did not understand or follow the law as instructed by the judge. 

    For example, if the jury awards an excessive or inadequate amount of damages in a civil case, the judge can reduce or increase the amount by granting a motion for remittitur or additur, respectively. 

    Remittitur means that the judge lowers the number of damages awarded by the jury, while additur means that the judge raises the number of damages awarded by the jury. 

    Alternatively, the judge can order a new trial on the issue of damages only.

    3. Guilty and Not Guilty

    In criminal cases, a jury can find a defendant guilty or not guilty of the charges against him or her. 

    A guilty verdict means that the jury believes that the prosecution has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the crime. 

    A not guilty verdict means that the jury has reasonable doubt about the defendant’s guilt, or that the defendant has raised a valid defense, such as self-defense or insanity. 

    A not guilty verdict does not necessarily mean that the defendant is innocent, but rather that he or she cannot be legally punished for the crime.

    4. Biased Jury Decisions

    Another reason why a judge may overrule a jury verdict is if there is evidence of bias or misconduct by the jury. 

    For example, if some jurors were influenced by external factors, such as media coverage, personal relationships, or bribes, that affected their impartiality and fairness. 

    Or if some jurors ignored or violated the judge’s instructions, such as conducting their own research, discussing the case with others, or lying during jury selection. 

    In such cases, the judge can declare a mistrial and order a new trial with a different jury.

    The Appellate Process and Overruling Jury Decisions

    Authority of appeals courts to review jury verdicts and judge’s actions

    An appeal is a legal process by which a party who is dissatisfied with the outcome of a trial can ask a higher court to review the case and determine if there were any errors of law or procedure that affected the verdict. 

    Appeals courts have the authority to:

    • Affirm the verdict and judgment of the lower court, meaning that they agree with the decision and uphold it
    • Reverse the verdict and judgment of the lower court, meaning that they disagree with the decision and overturn it
    • Remand the case to the lower court, meaning that they send the case back for further proceedings, such as a new trial or a new sentencing
    • Modify the verdict and judgment of the lower court, meaning that they change some aspects of the decision, such as reducing or increasing the amount of damages or the length of the sentence

    Standards for overturning a jury’s decision on appeal

    Appeals courts do not reweigh the evidence or reevaluate the credibility of witnesses that were presented at trial. 

    They defer to the jury’s findings of fact unless they are clearly erroneous or unreasonable. 

    Appeals courts review the judge’s rulings on legal issues, such as motions, objections, instructions, and post-trial motions, for errors of law. 

    Errors of law are mistakes in applying or interpreting the law that may have affected the jury’s verdict. 

    Appeals courts use different standards of review depending on the type and severity of the error. 

    Some common standards of review are:

    • De novo: The appeals court reviews the issue from scratch, without giving any deference to the lower court’s decision. This standard is used for pure questions of law, such as constitutional issues or statutory interpretation.
    • Abuse of discretion: The appeals court reviews the issue to determine if the lower court acted arbitrarily, unreasonably, or unfairly in exercising its discretion. This standard is used for issues that involve some degree of judgment or choice by the lower court, such as evidentiary rulings or sentencing decisions.
    • Substantial evidence: The appeals court reviews the issue to determine if there is enough evidence in the record to support the jury’s verdict. This standard is used for issues that involve factual determinations by the jury, such as liability or damages.

    Conclusion

    In summary, a judge can overrule the jury verdict in some cases, but not in others. The power and role of judges and juries in a court case depend on whether it is a criminal or civil case, and whether it is at the trial level or the appellate level. 

    Judges have the authority to oversee the legal process and ensure that the law is applied correctly and fairly, while juries have the power to evaluate the evidence and render a verdict based on the facts. 

    Judges can overrule the jury verdict and lower money damages, grant a judgment of acquittal, or order a new trial in limited circumstances, such as when no reasonable jury could have reached the given verdict when the jury did not understand or follow the law, or when there is evidence of bias or misconduct by the jury. 

    Appeals courts can review the jury verdict and the judge’s actions for errors of law or procedure that affected the verdict, and affirm, reverse, remand, or modify the decision of the lower court using different standards of review.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email Reddit WhatsApp
    Previous ArticleWhat are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Digital Marketing for eCommerce Businesses?
    Next Article Why Personalized Signs Are More Memorable Than Other Advertisements
    Avatar for Sayan Dutta
    Sayan Dutta
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn

    I am glad you came over here. So, you want to know a little bit about me. I am a passionate digital marketer, blogger, and engineer. I have knowledge & experience in search engine optimization, digital analytics, google algorithms, and many other things.

    Related Posts

    Best Buy Alternatives
    Lifestyle

    Top 11 “Best Buy” Alternatives for Your Electronics Needs in 2025

    May 11, 2025
    Shampoo-bars
    Lifestyle

    Benefits of Using a Shampoo Bar

    April 21, 2025
    Food & Beverage POS System
    Lifestyle

    Benefits of a Food & Beverage POS System

    April 7, 2025

    Table of Contents

    • Understanding the Power and Role of Judges and Juries in a Court Case
      • Judges’ Powers And Responsibilities
      • Jury’s Role In Determining Guilt Or Innocence
    • When a Judge Can Overturn a Jury Verdict?
      • 1. JNOV (Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict)
      • 2. Limited Understanding of Legal Matters
      • 3. Guilty and Not Guilty
      • 4. Biased Jury Decisions
    • The Appellate Process and Overruling Jury Decisions
      • Authority of appeals courts to review jury verdicts and judge’s actions
      • Standards for overturning a jury’s decision on appeal
    • Conclusion

    Top Posts

    SOA OS23

    SOA OS23: The Future Blueprint for Scalable, Agile Digital Systems

    May 29, 2025
    Inter vs. Estrella Roja

    Inter vs. Estrella Roja: Full Match Guide and Detailed Stats

    May 29, 2025
    VCWeather

    VCWeather.org: The New Face of Hyperlocal Weather Reporting

    May 28, 2025
    baltimore-orioles-vs-san-francisco-giants-match-player-sats

    Baltimore Orioles vs San Francisco Giants Match Player Stats

    May 28, 2025
    Popular in Social Media
    Anon IG Viewer

    Anon IG Viewer: Best Anonymous Viewer for Instagram

    April 3, 2025
    CFBR

    How to Use CFBR Appropriately? (Pros and Cons)

    September 24, 2024
    EU to Get WhatsApp, Messenger Interoperability with iMessage, Telegram and More

    EU to Get WhatsApp, Messenger Interoperability with iMessage, Telegram and More

    September 9, 2024
    New in Health
    9 Reasons Why People in Their 40s Should Take Daily Supplements

    9 Reasons Why People in Their 40s Should Take Daily Supplements

    April 8, 2025
    Why Put Your Tampons In The Freezer

    Why Put Your Tampons In The Freezer? (Answered)

    November 26, 2024
    WellHealthOrganic Buffalo Milk Tag

    WellHealthOrganic Buffalo Milk Tag: Unveiling Nutritional Brilliance

    November 13, 2024

    google news

    google-play-badge

    Protected by Copyscape

    DMCA.com Protection Status

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • About
    • Sitemap
    Copyright © 2025 - Read Us 24x7

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.