Italy fines Meta €805 million, about $887 million, over the Facebook app’s access to photos on Android phones. The Garante, Italy’s data protection authority, announced the decision on 14 November 2026 and gave Meta 60 days to switch the feature off by default and ask for separate consent. Meta says it will appeal.

What the Garante Found

The Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, to give the authority its full name, found that Facebook reached users’ photo galleries without valid consent. Its decision concerns a feature available since 2023 called Ottieni suggerimenti dalla galleria quando navighi su Facebook — “get suggestions from your gallery while browsing Facebook” — which proposes photos and videos from the phone’s gallery as posts.

The authority opened the case in July 2025 after a report from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection centre in Bolzano, and then ran its own technical analysis of the Android app. According to the Garante’s decision notice, the fine is €805 million, equal to about 0.47% of the group’s worldwide turnover.

The regulator’s specific objections were these:

  • One permission for many purposes: The Android app asked for gallery access through a single authorisation covering the whole app and several functions with different aims.
  • A vague prompt: The request followed a generic notice about enabling “other features” that did not make clear gallery suggestions were included.
  • On by default: The feature was switched on without the user choosing it.
  • Open-ended access: A full grant lets the app read the entire photo archive, normally on a continuing basis, and neither the user nor the authority can check what is actually used.

The decision rests on Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, the national law that implements the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive. That directive governs confidentiality of information stored on a user’s own device, separately from the General Data Protection Regulation. The Garante reads Article 122 as treating the smartphone as part of a person’s private sphere, so reaching its contents needs free and informed consent whether or not any data is sent anywhere and whether or not anyone is harmed.

In setting the amount the authority counted the number of people involved, the continuing nature of the breach for users who had not updated the app, a previous 2019 decision against the company, and what it described as limited cooperation during the investigation. It treated changes Meta made after the complaint as mitigating, but judged them late and limited to users who update the app.

Which Users the Decision Covers

The decision covers Android users of Facebook in Italy, and the Garante put that group at roughly 20 million people. It is a national measure addressed to Meta Platforms Ireland Limited; it does not order changes for users in other countries, and it does not concern the iPhone version of the app.

One point is easy to confuse. This case is about the gallery-suggestions feature that has existed since 2023, not about the separate “camera roll suggestions” feature Meta began rolling out in the European Union and the United Kingdom in April 2026. Of that newer feature Meta says in its own announcement, “You must opt in to use this feature, and you can turn it off at any time.” The Garante did not rule on it, and said it reserves the right to examine separately a 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud.

Anyone wanting to check the current state of these settings can find them in the Facebook app’s own privacy settings, where the labels vary by app version and region. The Garante publishes its decisions in its online register.

What Meta Must Do, and by When

The order sets three separate windows, and only one of them is about changing the product. The Garante stated them as periods in days rather than calendar dates; the dates below are counted from the decision date of 14 November 2026.

WindowDate counted from 14 November 2026What is required
30 days14 December 2026Meta must tell the Garante which steps it has begun.
60 days13 January 2027Consent must be sought through a separate, specific request naming the purpose, the gallery access and how to turn it off. The feature must be off by default.
90 days12 February 2027Meta must report the measures it has adopted.

Two details in the 60-day requirement go further than a simple default change. The feature must be off by default even for users who previously granted the app-wide permission, so people who believe they already allowed it are to be switched off and asked again. And if the 60 days pass without compliance, the feature cannot be activated at all for users who have not given valid consent.

As of 16 November 2026, the fine and the order stand and those windows are running. Meta has announced an appeal, but no suspension of the order has been reported, and the published decision notice does not say whether an appeal pauses the compliance dates.

Why Ireland Could Not Take the Case

Meta argued the case belonged to the Irish regulator, and the Garante rejected that argument. The reason is the legal basis it chose.

Under the GDPR, a company with its European base in one member state normally answers to that state’s authority for cross-border matters, a mechanism known as the one-stop-shop. Meta Platforms Ireland Limited is based in Dublin, which is why Ireland’s Data Protection Commission has led most European cases against the company — including the €403 million location-data fine against Google that the Irish authority announced in September 2026. The ePrivacy Directive contains no equivalent mechanism, so the Garante held that a case brought under Article 122 stays with the national authority that brought it.

The practical consequence reaches past Italy. Every member state has its own law implementing the same directive, so another national regulator could in principle examine the same feature on the same basis without waiting for Dublin. That is a possibility rather than a scheduled event: no other authority has announced such a case.

How This Fine Compares With Italy’s Earlier Meta Cases

Italy has pursued Meta several times through different bodies, and searches for this story often surface the older, much smaller matters. They are distinct cases with different regulators and different subjects.

ActionBodyAmountSubject
November 2026 fineGarante (data protection)€805 millionFacebook’s Android gallery access; Meta is appealing
June 2024 fineAGCM (competition and consumer)€3.5 millionTransparency over data use and account suspensions
2025 tax assessmentItalian tax authorities€887.6 million claimedVAT on free sign-ups; a claim under appeal, not a fine

The tax figure is worth separating carefully, because €887.6 million is close to the dollar value of this week’s fine. Reuters reported in July 2025 that Italy was claiming about €887.6 million from Meta in value added tax, on the argument that a free account exchanged for personal data is a taxable transaction, and that Meta had appealed to a first-instance tax court. That is a tax dispute rather than a penalty, its outcome was unresolved at the time of that reporting, and this routine could not confirm its current status.

Italy’s communications regulator, AGCOM, also fined Meta over gambling advertising in December 2023; outlets reported differing amounts for that penalty at the time. On the privacy side, the €805 million figure is far above anything the Garante had imposed before: GDPR enforcement trackers record its previous largest fine as roughly €79 million against the energy retailer Enel Energia in February 2024. Meta has faced larger European privacy penalties elsewhere, and separately lost ground in the United States, where a New Mexico ruling cut a $219.5 billion penalty calculation to a $25 billion judgment in October 2026.

What Is Still Undecided

Several parts of this remain open, and the decision notice is explicit about some of them.

  • The appeal: Meta has said it will appeal but has not published a filing date, a court or a hearing schedule. A spokesperson said the company strongly disagrees with the regulator’s assessment and considers the fine disproportionate, describing the feature as a way to help people share photos and videos.
  • Whether the clock pauses: Nothing in the published notice or in reporting so far establishes that filing an appeal suspends the 30, 60 and 90-day windows.
  • AI training: The proceeding did not examine whether gallery content was used to train artificial intelligence models. Meta denies doing so, and the Garante made no finding either way.
  • The newer cloud feature: The authority reserved the right to assess the 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud in a separate proceeding.
  • Other jurisdictions: Whether any other European regulator opens its own case under its national ePrivacy law is unknown.

Italy’s measure arrives while the European Union is tightening consumer rules on digital services more broadly, including the Digital Fairness Act proposed on 11 November 2026, which would set required wording for online cancellation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why Did Italy Fine Meta €805 Million?

Italy’s data protection authority found that the Facebook app on Android reached users’ photos, videos and related metadata without specific consent or adequate notice. It relied on Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive, in a decision announced on 14 November 2026.

Does the Fine Change Anything for Facebook Users Outside Italy?

Not directly. The order addresses Meta’s conduct toward Android users in Italy, put by the regulator at about 20 million people. Because the ePrivacy Directive has no one-stop-shop mechanism, other national regulators could examine the same feature under their own laws, but none has announced a case.

What Must Meta Change, and by When?

Within 60 days of the 14 November 2026 decision, Meta must keep the feature off by default — including for users who already granted the permission — and ask for separate, specific consent. It must report its initial steps within 30 days and the measures adopted within 90 days.

Is This the Same as Facebook’s Camera Roll Suggestions?

No. The fine concerns a gallery-suggestions feature available since 2023. The opt-in camera roll suggestions feature Meta rolled out in the EU and UK from April 2026 was not part of this proceeding, though the Garante said it may examine a 2026 cloud-processing feature separately.

Is Meta Paying the Fine?

Meta has said it strongly disagrees with the decision, considers the fine disproportionate and intends to appeal. As of 16 November 2026 it had not published a filing date or court, and no suspension of the order had been reported.